Challenges of Inaccessible PDFs in Banking & Insurance
-
Complex Financial and Policy Documents
Financial documents are often packed with intricate details, tables, graphs, and fine print that are challenging for assistive technologies to interpret. When PDFs are not properly tagged, screen readers struggle to maintain a logical reading order, making it difficult for users to navigate key information.
For instance, a loan applicant with a visual impairment might be unable to review their repayment schedule if the PDF lacks appropriate table headers and alt text. This lack of accessibility can result in uninformed financial decisions and unnecessary delays in critical processes.
-
Fraud Prevention and Security Concerns
Security measures such as CAPTCHAs, digital signatures, and OTP-based verifications are essential for fraud prevention but can become obstacles for users relying on assistive technology. Many of these security elements are embedded within PDFs, making them inaccessible to screen readers.
For example, if a blind user needs to verify their identity through an OTP-based PDF form that is not designed for accessibility, they may be unable to complete the authentication process. This can result in delays or even rejection of their financial applications.
-
Insurance Claims and Policy Accessibility Issues
Insurance documents, including claim forms and policy details, frequently use images instead of actual text, making it nearly impossible for screen readers to interpret the content. Additionally, policy renewals often require e-signatures, which may not be keyboard-navigable, posing challenges for users with motor impairments.
Consider a deaf customer who relies on speech-to-text technology. If an insurance disclaimer is embedded in a video without captions, they may miss critical policy information. Similarly, unclear premium breakdowns or inaccessible claim forms can make it difficult for individuals with disabilities to manage their insurance effectively.
Impact of Inaccessible PDFs on Specific User Groups
When businesses rely on PDFs for critical information, like banking statements, insurance policies, or investment reports, they often overlook how these documents affect users with disabilities. A poorly structured PDF can make it nearly impossible for some customers to access essential financial details, complete forms, or make informed decisions.
-
Customers with Visual Impairments (Blindness, Low Vision, Color Blindness)
For people who are blind or have low vision, screen readers are a lifeline. However, if a PDF is not properly structured with tags, tables, and alternative text, these tools may fail to interpret the content correctly. This is a major issue in banking and insurance documents where numbers, charts, and financial terms matter.
Example: A blind customer trying to compare two loan options would not be able to do so if the interest rate tables in a PDF are not tagged correctly for screen readers. Similarly, colorblind users struggle with visuals that rely solely on color to convey meaning. Imagine an investment risk chart where high-risk options are marked in red and low-risk ones in green. Without alternative indicators like patterns or labels, this information is lost on them.
-
Customers with Cognitive Disabilities (Dyslexia, ADHD, Autism)
Financial documents are already complex, and for users with cognitive disabilities, they can be overwhelming. Long, jargon-heavy paragraphs, inconsistent formatting, and non-intuitive layouts make it difficult to navigate important information.
Example: A customer with dyslexia may struggle to fill out an insurance claim form if it lacks a read-aloud feature or simplified text options. Without these accessibility features, essential services become frustratingly difficult to use.
-
Users with Motor Impairments (Parkinson’s, Quadriplegia, Arthritis)
For individuals with limited mobility, interacting with PDFs that require precise mouse movements can be a challenge. Many people with motor impairments rely on keyboard shortcuts or voice commands, but if a PDF is not designed with this in mind, critical banking and insurance processes become inaccessible.
Example: A customer with paralysis might not be able to update their insurance policy if the digital form requires dragging and dropping elements instead of allowing keyboard-based navigation.
-
Users with Deafness or Hard of Hearing
While PDFs are primarily text-based, they sometimes include multimedia elements like embedded videos for policy explanations or claim processing. If these videos do not have captions, they exclude users who are deaf or hard of hearing from crucial information.
Example: A customer applying for home insurance may miss important policy disclosures if they are presented in a video without real-time captions or transcripts.
| Issues | Problems | Impacts | User Experience |
|---|---|---|---|
| Complex Financial & Policy Documents | PDFs with intricate details, tables, and graphs are not properly tagged. | Screen readers struggle to interpret content, making navigation difficult. | Users with visual impairments may be unable to review critical financial details. |
| Fraud Prevention & Security Concerns | CAPTCHAs, digital signatures, and OTP verifications are inaccessible. | Users relying on assistive technology face authentication barriers. | Blind users may be unable to complete identity verification processes. |
| Insurance Claims & Policy Accessibility Issues | Policy details often use images instead of text, making them unreadable. | Screen readers cannot interpret text embedded in images or inaccessible forms. | Deaf users may miss disclaimers in videos without captions. |
| Customers with Visual Impairments | PDFs lack proper tagging, alt text, and screen reader compatibility. | Essential financial details are inaccessible. | Blind users cannot compare loan options if interest rate tables are untagged. |
| Customers with Cognitive Disabilities | Overly complex language and formatting make documents hard to read. | Users struggle to comprehend critical financial terms. | A dyslexic customer may struggle to fill out claim forms without read-aloud features. |
| Users with Motor Impairments | PDFs require precise mouse movements or dragging/dropping elements. | Navigation and form completion become difficult. | A user with paralysis may not be able to update their insurance policy. |
| Users with Deafness or Hard of Hearing | Embedded videos lack captions. | Critical policy details may be missed. | A deaf customer may not receive policy disclosures if they are in an uncaptioned video. |
| Compliance Risks | Failure to meet legal accessibility requirements (ADA, WCAG, EAA). | Risk of lawsuits, fines, and reputational damage. | Over 2,400 lawsuits were filed in 2022 against banks for digital inaccessibility. |
Compliance Risks: Legal and Regulatory Challenges for Financial Institutions
- ADA Digital Accessibility Lawsuits – Over 2,400 lawsuits were filed in 2022 against banks for inaccessible websites and mobile apps. Ensuring digital accessibility is critical.
- Section 508 Compliance – Government-affiliated banks must make digital banking PDFs accessible for users with disabilities.
- WCAG 2.2 for Insurers – Insurance companies must ensure policy documents and claim forms meet accessibility standards.
- European Accessibility Act (EAA) – Financial service providers in Europe must comply by June 28, 2025, or face fines.
